"The Show Could Never Quite Recover Without Him": People Are Sharing The Character Departures That Ruined The TV Show For Them
We recently asked the BuzzFeed Community which TV characters were written off the show too soon. Here are some of the characters fans who wish had stuck around longer (plus a few of my own additions):
?? Spoilers ahead, including for House of the Dragon and Stranger Things!!! ??
1.Andy from Modern Family
"Haley was her best self with him. I'm not saying she needed a man in the end, but Andy was much, MUCH better for her than Dylan."
—ns67
2.Laena from House of the Dragon
"Okay, I know her character dies in the books, but hear me out: We deserved at least one more episode with her. I really wanted to see her and Daemon's relationship develop, and also wanted more scenes of her and Rhaenyra together. Giving her character more screen time would have made her death even more impactful."
3.Lexa from The 100
"Yes, her and Clarke never got the chance to be happy, and I will forever be angry about the 'bury your gays' trope the writers fed into, but I was also really excited to see more of Lexa's storyline as a leader. I wanted to see how the new relationship would have affected her leadership, how she would have handled the prime fire, and how the Sky People (Skaikru) would have been incorporated into the Trikru (Grounders) society."
"She and Clarke deserved at least ONE WEEK of happiness. Her death still makes me furious."
4.Eddie from Stranger Things
"I legit had a complete breakdown when he died...snot and everything."
"Eddie. F*cking. Munson."
5.George from Grey's Anatomy
"He was funny, sweet, a best friend to all, and ridiculously great at his job and with patients. Putting aside the actor's desire to leave the show...why kill him off? He had a great out — he could have gone off to be a trauma surgeon in the army. Why did he have to get hit by a bus? Why kill him?! What was the point — to break his mom's already broken heart? To break our hearts? Poor George! He deserved better!"
Note: The show did "bring back" George while Meredith was in a dream-like state in Season 17 (pictured above).
6.Casey Parker from Grey's Anatomy
"We need more trans characters played by trans actors, and he was a great character. I needed more of him!"
7.Peach from YOU
"They killed her off too soon. It would have paid off more for the plot if they kept her alive."
8.Nathan from Misfits
"Robert Sheehan brought such a unique, chaotic madness to that role and was a clear fan favorite. When he left, the quality noticeably dropped and just kept getting worse. The show could never quite recover without Nathan."
"I loved the show and watched it from beginning to end, but once Robert Sheehan left the show, it just felt empty. It was never the same."
9.Jess from Gilmore Girls
"His character had the most illogical timing. He came in too early, so the writers made Dean more and more annoying to contrast him, and then he just left end of Season 3. After that, Jess was only used to tell Rory to get her shit together, and then for her to cheat on Logan. Rory should have left Logan in Season 6 and either been single or with Jess."
10.Dave from Gilmore Girls
"He was Lane's love interest in Season 3, and I was so invested in their adorable relationship. It's tough because the actor left to play another one of my favorite characters, Seth Cohen on The O.C., but I still really wanted Dave and Lane to end up together. I liked Zack, but not with Lane — Dave and Lane will forever be an OTP in my book."
11.Maya from Pretty Little Liars
"Her death was incredibly pointless and cruel. Killing her off caused Emily so much trauma, did nothing to add to the central mystery, and wasn't even in the books. Even if Emison was the endgame plan, the writers could have easily just written Maya off another way or replaced the Pailey scenes with Emaya instead. Maya deserved better!"
12.Zack from Bones
"I can't believe they made him a serial killer apprentice to write him off the show."
Note: Despite being out of the picture for several seasons, Zack did eventually return in Season 12.
13.Catelyn Stark from Game of Thrones
"Michelle Fairley should have come back to the show for the Lady Stoneheart storyline. She would have been AMAZING, and it would have cemented the romantic relationship between Jaime and Brienne. It was such a missed opportunity!"
14.Colin Zabel from Mare of Easttown
"Mare and Colin had just started getting to know each other, and we were starting to get to know his character. Then, BOOM! He was dead. Colin deserved better!"
15.Tori from Degrassi: The Next Generation
"Tori had SO MUCH potential. First of all, the actor was the real-life sister of Cassie Steele (Manny), and could have easily been the new 'it girl' of her generation if the writers had actually given her storylines. Additionally, I think Tristan's character would have been much more tolerable had Tori stuck around. She was the glue that held that Grade 9 friend group together, and it fell apart without her."
16.Peyton and Lucas from One Tree Hill
"I wanted to see them interact with Clay, Quinn, and Alex so badly. Having Lucas and Peyton around would have made the later seasons better."
17.Keith from One Tree Hill
"Keith Scott from One Tree Hill, hands down."
"His murder was one of the most shocking teen drama moments of all time. Although his death changed things up and gave everyone character development, I can't help but feel the show would have been better if Keith and Karen had just gotten to be happy together."
18.Mark from Parks and Recreation
"I know this will be controversial, but I wish Mark had stayed on Parks and Rec longer. He was definitely more annoying in the first season — he was kind of dismissive and a womanizer. But then he grew a lot, and his scene helping fix up Ron's workshop was a great example of showing what he could bring to the team. I wish they would have at least mentioned him or his plan for the park that he gave Leslie during his departure. It was such a sweet gesture, but they seemed to completely forget about it."
19.Luke from The O.C.
"He started off as a bully and complete jerk but had such great character development over the course of Season 1. I loved how he eventually became a really good friend to Ryan, especially during the Oliver storyline. They should have kept him and Anna on the show longer instead of adding in so many new characters in Season 2."
20.Vanessa from Party of Five (2020)
"Amanda Arcuri being part of the cast was a big reason I was so excited for this show, and I was bummed that her character was written out so quickly. I thought Emilio had the best chemistry with Vanessa, and I loved how she was so kind and helpful to his siblings. It's a shame the show got cancelled after just one season, too."
21.Adrian from Brooklyn Nine-Nine
"I loved his and Rosa's relationship and weird sexual chemistry. I don't understand having Jason Mantzoukas as a love interest and not ending up with him."
22.And finally: Rayna from The Vampire Diaries
"She was such a good character and was easy to sympathize with. She was by far the best hunter on the entire show. She also gave us more Bonenzo and Bamon, which the show needed."
Reminder that I, Kelly Martinez, do not necessarily endorse all of these opinions!!!
Note: Submissions have been edited for length and/or clarity.
Get your heart pumping with Fall, a new thriller that will take you to terrifying heights. Watch it on demand right now, and on DVD/Blu-ray on October 18.
