Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

Find the best burgers in downtown Indianapolis at these restaurants

Cheryl V. Jackson and Bradley Hohulin, Indianapolis Star
Updated
4 min read

Between local joints and chains, mouth-watering burgers abound in Indianapolis. And some of the best have a presence downtown.

Even better, they often are paired with the city's best fries.

Here are the top places to grab a burger while in the downtown area.

Any way you slice it: Downtown Indianapolis has great pizza. Here's what's worth trying and what's the best

Baby’s

2147 N. Talbott St., Indianapolis, 317-600-3559, babysindy.com 

A triple stack version of the Baby's Strut house burger at Baby's Diner in Indianapolis is loaded down with smoked gouda, mango chutney, pickles, bacon and spicy, creamy, secret Dazzle Sauce. The restaurant opened Sept. 20, 2019, at 2147 N. Talbott St., at Herron Morton.
A triple stack version of the Baby's Strut house burger at Baby's Diner in Indianapolis is loaded down with smoked gouda, mango chutney, pickles, bacon and spicy, creamy, secret Dazzle Sauce. The restaurant opened Sept. 20, 2019, at 2147 N. Talbott St., at Herron Morton.

The retro-style diner offers smash burgers, boozy milkshakes and cocktails. The heated enclosed patio is dog-friendly.

Bru Burger Bar

410 Massachusetts Ave., Indianapolis, 317-635-4278, bruburgerbar.com

Bru Burger Bar's Garlic-Three Cheese burger.
Bru Burger Bar's Garlic-Three Cheese burger.

A favorite burger on the menu is the juicy Garlic-Three Cheese option with Swiss, American and mozzarella and soft cloves of garlic and truffle aioli.

Advertisement
Advertisement

Downtown breakfast: The best places to dine

Burgeezy

335 W. 9th St., Suite D, burgeezy.com

Nestled along the east side of the Canal Walk, Burgeezy is a Black-owned counter-service restaurant offering vegan comfort food that looks ripped from your favorite greasy spoon’s menu despite not featuring a single animal product.

Conner's Kitchen and Bar

350 W. Maryland St., connersindy.com

True to its billing as "a higher class of casual," Conner's' lone burger option is a $22 Wagyu cheeseburger. A 1/2 pound brisket blend joins your choice of lettuce, onion, pickles, tomato, American cheese secret sauce, served with fries. If that's not enough, you can add thick-cut bacon for $3.

Advertisement
Advertisement

Others are reading: Forget pineapple on pizza. Does peanut butter belong on a cheeseburger? We did a taste test

The District Tap

141 S. Meridian St., thedistricttap.com

District Tap's robust burger menu features all manner of toppings, from fried jalape?os and pepper jack cream cheese to cherry wood-smoked bacon and onion straws. You can even get something called boom-boom sauce, if you dare.

Fat Dan’s Chicago-style Deli

410 E. Michigan St., Indianapolis, 317-600-3008, fatdansdeli.com

Fat Dan's Fat Burger.
Fat Dan's Fat Burger.

You have to open wide to take in the Fat Burger with American cheese.  It comes on a grilled bun and with potato chips.

Flatiron at The Point on Penn

605 N. Pennsylvania St., Indianapolis, 317-746-6961, thepointonpenn.com

The Flatiron Burger at The Point on Penn
The Flatiron Burger at The Point on Penn

The eight-ounce Flatiron Burger is made of 21-day aged chuck-brisket topped with cheese, bacon and more. Comes with house-made potato chips.

Advertisement
Advertisement

New restaurants: Indianapolis-area restaurants you've got to try in January

Fogo de Chao

117 E. Washington St., Indianapolis, 317-638-4000, fogodechao.com

The Picanha Burger features beef ground in-house and is topped with smoked provolone, Bibb lettuce, tomato, onion and chimichurri aioli on brioche. It's served with a stack of thick crispy Parmesan polenta fries.

Kuma’s Corner

1127 Prospect St., Indianapolis, 317-929-1287, kumascorner.com

Kuma's Corner burger.
Kuma's Corner burger.

This metal-themed spot has huge, 10-ounce patties served on sturdy pretzel buns.  (Gluten-free buns are available.) Topping combos include smoked bacon and barbecue pulled pork; herbed goat cheese, poblano sweet corn relish, Cholula lemon vinaigrette and buttermilk breaded deep-fried red onions. Each comes with hand-cut fries or house-made potato chips.

Advertisement
Advertisement

Best steakhouses: Top places in downtown Indianapolis

Loughmiller's Pub

301 W. Washington St., loughmillerspub.com

Located just off the Cultural Trail near the Canal, Loughmiller's serves up burgers and brews in homage to its owners' cigar-smoking, beer-drinking Scotch-Irish ancestor, Joe Loughmiller Stacey. The fare at Loughmiller's features several pub classics, but the burger menu packs plenty of variety on its own. The skillet burger comes doused in chili and cheese atop Texas toast, while a tangle of French's onions and bacon crowns the Loughmiller's cheeseburger. There's even a Wagyu burger for the high rollers.

Shake Shack

231 N. Pennsylvania St., Indianapolis, shakeshack.com

The Smokeshack and Shackburger from Shake Shack
The Smokeshack and Shackburger from Shake Shack

This New York brand has a cult following for its smash burgers, chicken sandwiches and hand-spun shakes.

Steak ’n Shake

101 W. Maryland St., Indianapolis,  317-634-8703, steaknshake.com

Steak 'n Shake's parent company is gearing up for a takeover battle.
Steak 'n Shake's parent company is gearing up for a takeover battle.

Still serving up the smash burgers we’ve loved for years, along with shakes and super thin crispy fries.

The Oakmont

323 N. Delaware St., Indianapolis,  463-206-2108, theoakmontindy.com

The O.G. Burger at The Oakmont
The O.G. Burger at The Oakmont

The juicy O.G. Burger has an eight-ounce chuck/brisket/short rib beef blend with sharp cheddar and thick slices of bacon, garlic aioli, shredded lettuce, sliced tomato and red onion on a brioche bun.

Advertisement
Advertisement

Indylicious: Sign up for local dining news

Turchetti's Delicatessen & Meat Market

1110 Prospect St., Indianapolis, 317-426-3048,  turchettis.com

The smash burger stars a four-ounce bacon-blended beef patty with meat sourced from Indiana farms and served on a Leviathan seeded bun. Accompanying fries are cooked in tallow.

The Workingman's Friend Tavern

234 N. Belmont Ave., Indianapolis, 317-636-2067, facebook.com/The-Workingmans-Friend

You need cash if you want the signature Giant Double Cheeseburger — and if you love cheeseburgers, you definitely want this stack of two smash burgers, a middle piece bun, shredded lettuce and tomato. No plastic accepted.

Advertisement
Advertisement

Contact IndyStar reporter Cheryl V. Jackson at [email protected] or 317-444-6264. Follow her on Twitter: @cherylvjackson.

This article originally appeared on Indianapolis Star: College football championship: Best burgers in downtown Indianapolis

Solve the daily Crossword

The Daily Crossword was played 11,212 times last week. Can you solve it faster than others?
CrosswordCrossword
Crossword
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement