Why Melanie Lynskey Says Jason Ritter's Proposal Was "So Confusing"
Originally appeared on E! Online
Melanie Lynskey may have heard the wilderness, but she didn't quite hear Jason Ritter's marriage proposal.
In fact, the Yellowjackets star had no idea she was engaged to the Parenthood alum until he announced it to their families three days later. Describing Jason's 2016 proposal as "so confusing," Melanie admittedly "didn't know what was happening" when he popped the question.
"The day before, I had been looking at rings and I tried one on and I was like 'Oh, kind of looks like an engagement ring almost. I don't think I'm going to get it,'" she explained during her April 29 appearance on The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon. "So then, he got me this ring, so I was like, 'Oh, thanks!'"
The 46-year-old said "it didn't cross my mind" that Jason, 44, was actually proposing, so she unknowingly glossed over what the actor said to her when he presented the ring as some sort of "strange speech."
"We were just sort of sitting there," Melanie recalled to host Jimmy Fallon. "And I was like, 'We're not breaking up?'"
Celebrity Couples Who Found Love on Set
More from E! Online
Why Boston Mom Was Not Charged After 4 Babies Were Found Dead in Freezer Wrapped in Tin Foil
Jersey Shore's Pauly D Shares Rare Update on Life With 10-Year-Old Daughter Amabella
After Jason assured her that he had no intentions of calling it quits, the Last of Us actress remembered telling him, "'Well, thank you. Lovely. Good chat!'"
And since the first proposal didn't go as planned, the couple—who tied the knot in 2020—had a "very cute" do-over during a recent trip to Slovakia.
"He's been proposing to me over and over," Melanie shared of Jason, with whom she shares a 5-year-old daughter, "which is very sweet."
For more creative celeb proposals, keep reading.
Millie Bobby Brown and Jake Bongiovi
The Stranger Things star revealed that fiancé Jake Bongiovi popped the question while scuba diving on vacation.
"So we go under and we're like, many meters down and he gives me a shell and I turn it over and it's a ring," Millie explained on The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon. "And I looked at him, and he was like ‘Blurgh?'"
Logan Lerman and Ana Corrigan
The Perks of Being a Wallflower star proposed to longtime girlfriend Ana Corrigan in 2023 during a day out in Central Park, although it didn’t go as expected.
“My fiancée pointed out the rowboats and I was like, 'Oh, let's do it,” Logan explained on The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon. “I was terrible at it. So she ended up rowing the boat. I'm just sitting back. I'm thinking, 'Oh God, now people are looking at us and pointing and laughing at me.'"
After Ana rowed the two to a quiet part of the lake, Logan proposed, and as he put it, “It was great. It went really well.”
John Stamos and Caitlin McHugh
Bob Iger—only the CEO of the Walt Disney Company at the time—emailed Johnt after noticing how big of a Disney fanatic Caitlin seemed to be, going by her Instagram. His suspicions were confirmed and Iger gave his blessing to have John' animator pal Paul Briggs splice together all of the most romantic Disney and Pixar movie moments for the Full House star's proposal.
Obviously, John took Caitlin to Disneyland, where they watched the finished product and he both popped the question and kissed the girl.
Gabrielle Union and Dwayne Wade
It was a family affair when Wade proposed to the Bring It On star in 2013.
"We were just spending what I thought to be a fun day with the kids, having a little quality time," Gabrielle shared on Good Morning America in 2014. After brunch, they went to tour their home that was under renovation at the time.
"They were like, 'We wanna do a presentation for you,'" Gabrielle said. "They like to do skits and songs and stuff, so we turn around, and they're like, 'Okay, we're ready!' and I turn back around and [the kids] were holding up signs that said, 'Will you marry us?'"
Then she turned around and Dwyane was down on one knee.
Tara Lipinski and Todd Kapostasy
In time for Christmas in 2015, Todd commissioned a painting of himself proposing to his champion figure skater girlfriend in front of her house in California and had it set up inside a display window at the Plaza Hotel in New York.
Perfect scores across the board for program components and technical difficulty.
Neil Patrick Harris and David Burtka
These longtime loves both did the honors, with David offering up a ring first in 2007 on the New York street corner where they first met—Ninth Avenue between 44th and 45th.
"I thought he wanted to get some booze or something," NPH recalled to Out in 2012, remembering how David had their car pull over suddenly when they were on their way to a casino. "And then he got on one knee and proposed, and I was so freaked out by it that I said, 'Yes,' but I didn't know what it meant. Then I got the ring and loved it, and a year later, on Valentine's Day, I proposed to him in Santa Monica."
Sofía Vergara and Joe Manganiello
Joe prepared his proposal in his Colombian-born girlfriend's native Spanish and popped the question on Christmas Eve 2014 in Kauai.
The True Blood star later said he wanted to propose on the beach, but the paparazzi were everywhere, so he settled for inside the luxurious St. Regis Hotel, where they were staying. And it sufficed.
"We had this big bay window, and the sun was going down pink over the mountains and over the bay, and I had this ring," he told Haute Living. "I had looked at every ring in the world, and this is the ring that I wanted. I had a whole speech prepared in Spanish. I proposed to her on one knee in Spanish with the sun going down. It was awesome."
The couple tied the knot in 2015, but split nearly eight years later. Joe filed for divorce in July 2023, citing "irreconcilable differences," according to documents obtained by E! News.
Emmy Rossum and Sam Esmail
The Shameless star had a tradition of reading the New York Times' "Modern Love" column to the Mr. Robot creator every weekend, even if it had to be over the phone. After they skipped a Sunday, Sam insisted Emmy read the column the following Friday—which, suffering from a backache, she begrudgingly said she'd do from the bathtub.
"I didn't notice any kind of ring in his pocket, and I began to read the article, and the story is about a director who falls in love with an actress, and I started to think: Huh, that's strange," Rossum told the story to Vogue. "And then I realized that it was our love story. At first, I freaked out because I thought perhaps he had actually put it in the paper and I hadn't seen it, and everyone knew it but me. And then, I kind of scanned to the end and it said, 'Love, your Sam.' And I realized that he had gone through this whole process of writing this whole story."
Sam called in a favor at the Times to have his essay printed to look like a legit page in the paper, featuring a Ralph Lauren ad at the bottom and everything.
Pink and Carey Hart
The "Raise Your Glass" singer took the bull by the horns and proposed to her motocross-racing beau when he was mid-lap in scenic Mammoth Lakes, Calif., in June 2005. As Carey passed, Pink held up a sign reading, "WILL U MARRY ME?" And on the next turn: "SERIOUS!"
He pulled over and said yes.
"I said, 'Well, yeah of course,'" Carey recalled in a Supercross 2014 interview, "and she said, 'Well, get your ass back on the track. I don't marry losers.'"
Kim Kardashian and Kanye West
Of course, Kanye went all out to pop the question in October 2013, renting out the San Francisco Giants' house, AT&T Park, and imploring Kim to marry him via the jumbotron while a 50-piece orchestra played Lana Del Rey's "Young and Beautiful," followed by Keri Hilson, Ne-Yo and Kanye's "Knock You Down."
Not surprisingly, there were literal fireworks.
The couple tied the knot in 2014, and Kim ultimately filed for divorce in 2021, according to documents obtained by E! News. The "Donda" singer married model Bianca Censori in 2022.
Shawn Johnson and Andrew East
The Olympic gold medalist had just thrown out the first pitch at Wrigley Field with teammate Alicia Sacramone when her boyfriend got down on one knee in June 2015.
Beau Clark and Stassi Schroeder
Knowing how much Stassi loves true crime and the macabre, Beau popped the question at Hollywood Forever Cemetery in July 2019.
Don Lemon and Tim Malone
In April 2019, Tim had special tags engraved and sent the couple's poodle mixes, Boomer and Barkley, over to their other dad with a special question.
"He gave me a present on his birthday," Don wrote on Instagram. "How could I say no?"
Katy Perry and Orlando Bloom
On Valentine's Day in 2019, after dinner at an Italian restaurant in New York, Orlando proposed during a helicopter ride. He gave Katy a love note ostensibly to distract her while he pulled the ring box out of his pocket, and the champagne sloshed around a bit, but overall, it was "really sweet," the singer said.
The night only got better when, upon landing, Orlando had arranged for 30 friends and family members to be waiting for them to celebrate their engagement.
Lee Loechler and Sthuthi David
Lee's January 2020 proposal rightly made them celebrities for a news cycle when he took Sthuthi—his high school sweetheart—to a screening of Sleeping Beauty (in cahoots with Sthuthi's mom), and the shot of Prince Phillip waking Aurora up from her cursed sleep with a kiss was edited to look like cartoon versions of Lee and Sthuthi, courtesy of illustrator Kayla Coombs. And then his cartoon self made as if he was tossing Lee the ring to give to his beloved and urges him to get to it.
"She was sort of expecting the proposal around this time so I knew I had to be pretty sneaky if I wanted to give her a good surprise, because she is very astute, no pun intended, and you know she's a doctor so she is very smart, very cerebral," Lee told E! News after the video of his carefully laid plan panning out went viral.
Good thing Sthuthi's a cardiologist because... be still our hearts!
Peacock is live now! Check out NBCU's streaming service here.
