I’m Retired and Regret Claiming Social Security at 70 — Here’s Why
We’ve all heard the advice: Wait until you’re 70 to claim Social Security and you’ll get the biggest possible monthly check. Tim F., a retired healthcare worker from Arizona, followed this advice to the letter. But now, at 75, he’s having second thoughts.
Find Out: I’m Retired and Regret My Frugal Retirement — Here’s Why
Explore More: 5 Low-Risk Ways To Build Your Retirement Savings in 2025
GOBankingRates spoke with Tim to understand why he wishes he’d claimed his benefits earlier. His insights might just change the way you think about your own retirement plans.
Trending Now: Suze Orman's Secret to a Wealthy Retirement--Have You Made This Money Move?
The Waiting Game: Not All It’s Cracked Up To Be
Tim thought he was doing everything right.
“Everything you read says you should wait until 70 if you can,” he shared. “I guess I thought, well, I can, so I should. I didn’t stop to think about if that was actually the best plan for me.”
Tim likes larger monthly checks, but he’s not sure they were worth the price.
“Looking back, I would’ve wanted that extra money when my wife was still around.”
The Heartbreak No One Talks About
Tim’s wife, Sarah, passed away at 68 before they could claim their benefits together.
“Sarah and I had plans,” Tim shared. “We were definitely thinking in the long term when we probably should’ve been more realistic about how much time we had left.”
Tim is not sure what advice comes out of this other than live for today (and make sure to go to the doctor regularly).
When Your Body Has Other Plans
Tim said he didn’t give much thought to how his own health might change as he got older.
“I’m not as active as I was in my 30s — heck, even my 40s,” he said. “When you get older, a year means potentially a lot of health changes. I wish I’d just taken the money earlier and used it partially for trips and partially in a high-interest savings account. Hindsight is 20/20!”
The ‘Break-Even’ Point: A Moving Target
Financial advisors talk about the “break-even point” — that’s the age when the total benefits you get from waiting outweigh what you would’ve gotten by claiming earlier.
“They told me I’d break even around 82,” Tim said. “But when you’re 75, 82 feels pretty far off. I wish I’d thought more about enjoying the present rather than always planning for the future.”
The Investment Opportunity That Got Away
Tim didn’t consider the potential to invest some of his Social Security income if he’d claimed earlier.
“I’m not an investing powerhouse,” Tim shared. “But I could’ve put the money in a high-interest savings account and made it work for me. Oh well.”
The Hidden Cost: Stress
Perhaps the biggest impact for Tim wasn’t financial at all — it was the stress of waiting.
“The years before 70, I was always second-guessing myself,” he shared. “Should we claim now? Are we making a huge mistake? I kinda drove myself — and everyone around me — a little nuts.”
Tim’s Words of Wisdom
Tim doesn’t believe waiting until 70 is wrong for everyone. But he does have some advice for those trying to make this decision:
Consider your health: “Be realistic about how you might feel in 5 years.”
Talk it over with your significant other — it’s not a good decision if it’s not made together.
Think about what you want to do in retirement. Travel? Spend time with grandkids? Take up knitting? Make a list and let your finances follow.
Look at your other income sources — side hustles don’t have to end with retirement.
More From GOBankingRates
This article originally appeared on GOBankingRates.com: I’m Retired and Regret Claiming Social Security at 70 — Here’s Why
Solve the daily Crossword
