SheKnows and Yahoo may earn commission from links in this article. Pricing and availability subject to change.

We Asked 4 Teen Boys To Test These New Fall Fragrances — Here’s What They Had To Say

We Asked 4 Teen Boys To Test These New Fall Fragrances — Here’s What They Had To Say


If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, SheKnows may receive an affiliate commission.


No matter what, teens will always have autonomy over what’s cool. It’s like their right of passage for having to go through all the woes of puberty while being close to adulthood but still far from it. And for this generation of cool teens, the guys seem to know all about what’s “in” when it comes to fragrance. Gone are the days when an overpowering AXE Body Spray could suffice. Now, they’re more locked in than ever — hitting up Sephora stores and perfume counters to find their go-to scent.

More from SheKnows

Today's Top Deals


Because we wanted to stay ahead of the trends, we sought some aroma help. As part of SheKnows’s Be a Man series, we collaborated with the editors at Robb Report and tapped four guys ages 15-20 to give three new colognes debuting this month the sniff test, from an iconic brand that launched a signature eau de toilette that smells “fresh” (according to our testers) to a pricey scent that’s perfect for date night. The catch? We didn’t tell them what they were smelling beforehand. How closely did they guess the correct fragrance notes? And how closely (ahem, or not) were they on the price point of each one? Check out what our testers had to say — and how to get your hands on one of these new fragrances before the holiday season. Who knows? Maybe one of these colognes will be the perfect gift for the teen boy in your life, and you’ll have these guys to thank for that.

4 Teen Boys Test New Gucci Guilty Cologne & More Ahead of the Holidays
4 Teen Boys Test New Gucci Guilty Cologne & More Ahead of the Holidays

Gucci Guilty Essence Eau de Toilette in 1.6 ounces

$99

Buy Now on Nordstrom

$99

Buy Now on SEPHORA

$99

Buy Now on ulta

When most of the guys smelled Gucci Guilty’s latest Essence scent, “Fresh” came to mind. Theo, 14, said, “This might be an everyday wear in the summer; it reminds me of a forest.” It has key notes of lavender, orange flowers, and cedarwood for a light, earth scent that Zach, 20, said reminded him of “waking up and going to school. Getting myself ready, preparing myself to be fresh for the day.”


4 Teen Boys Test New Gucci Guilty Cologne & More Ahead of the Holidays
4 Teen Boys Test New Gucci Guilty Cologne & More Ahead of the Holidays

Mind Games Prodigy

$475

Buy Now

As the brand name would suggest, this new fragrance by Mind Games will have your brain questioning what exactly that smell is. Most of the boys enjoyed the scent but couldn’t pinpoint exactly what it smelled like to them. “Oh, this is a complex fragrance; there’s a lot of notes going on,” Clive, 15, said while trying to describe its scent. Finn, 19, described it as a “nighttime vibe” and said, “It’s a little sweeter, a little warmer.” It has earthy notes of sandalwood blended with Madagascar vanilla, Longoza blossom, rose absolute, cinnamon bark, and bergamots.


4 Teen Boys Test New Gucci Guilty Cologne & More Ahead of the Holidays
4 Teen Boys Test New Gucci Guilty Cologne & More Ahead of the Holidays

Frédéric Malle Hope by Dominique Ropion in 100ml

$1,140

Buy Now

“This is definitely for a date night; I would not have this for everyday wear,” Theo said, smelling Dominique Ropion’s new Hope fragrance. It has base notes of amber and leather that bleed into oud oil and finish with pink pepper and juniper oil.



Before you go, check out

More Top Deals from SheKnows

Best of SheKnows

Sign up for SheKnows' Newsletter. For the latest news, follow us on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram.