Best flip-flops for women in 2024, tested and reviewed

Sizes: 5 to 12 | Colors: 36 options | Material: Rubber

With more than 6,400 customer reviews and an impressive 4.6-star rating, these Olukai flip-flops are one of the most popular pairs of sandals on Amazon, and it’s easy to see why. Along with a non-slip EVA insole that’s cushioned for added comfort, the popular flip-flops also feature a water-resistant upper strap and a durable rubber sole. The footbed has a molded foot cup, which was one element Dr. Daughtry says to look for as a "heel cup allows for the heel to nestle in the shoe to avoid walking out of the shoe quite as easily." One happy shopper calls them "the best flip-flop the world has to offer," and adds "Once I tried them I couldn't believe how comfortable they were. They conform to your actual feet to provide support and relief from foot pain."

Sizes: 5 to 11 | Colors: 30 options | Material: 100% thermoplastic polyurethane

New York based podiatrist and foot surgeon, Dr. Hillary Brenner is a fan of these FitFlop flip-flops, which are made from thermoplastic polyurethane (providing excellent wear resistance and optimal cushioning) and have an APMA Seal of Acceptance for footwear found to promote good foot health. "I like the FitFlop brand ... the arch is thick with a wide chunky heel giving extra support," she says. The biomechanically engineered sandals are slip-resistant and have an air-foam footbed that retains its cushioning and helps put a bounce in your step — even on long walks. One happy shopper writes, "These flip-flops are great! They have a nice arch and a cushioned heel. I can wear them all day they are that comfortable!"

Sizes: 6 to 11 | Colors: Seven options | Materials: Thermoplastic Rubber, Polyester

Powerstep uses podiatrists as consultants for the brand so you know their shoes will give you the all-day support you need. These sleek sandals have a contoured arch, shock-absorbing cushioning, and a deep heel cradle that helps provide stability for your foot. The orthotic sandals also have a non-slip grip on the bottoms and a soft thick thong strap that feels good against the foot. "These flip-flops felt perfect from the first moment I stepped into them. Good fit at the heel, great fit between the toes, and the arch support is wonderful," says one customer. "These flip-flops allow your foot to remain relaxed while walking."

Sizes: 5 to 11 | Colors: Four options | Materials: Closed cell foam

These sturdy sandals have an APMA Seal of Acceptance for promoting good foot health and being of exceptional quality. This flip-flop features the brand’s signature Oofoam technology that helps cushion your foot while you walk. The brand's special tech also absorbs 37% more impact than regular footwear foam and it has a deep heel cup that offers great support for people with ailments like plantar fasciitis. The patented footbed cradles your arches to minimize stress on your feet, knees and back. "These are my latest favorite," Dr. Melissa Lockwood, DPM, tells us. "They last a long time and have a great footbed." Dr. Daughtry agrees, telling us, "They offer great shock absorption and cushioning but great arch support." One of the hundreds of five-star reviewers writes, "I have plantar fasciitis and thought my flip-flop days were over. [I] was so happy that these were comfortable and that I could wear them for extended periods."

Sizes: 5 to 12 | Colors: 19 options | Material: Rubber

While these flip-flops do have a flat footbed, they are easily one of the most popular options if you are looking for a classic rubber version to wear to the beach or pool. Our Senior Health Editor, April McCormick, considers herself a "flip-flop connoisseur" and says these are by far her favorite pair. Seriously, she has about 50 pairs at home, some of which are up to 15 years old! "They are comfy, indestructible, come in a ton of styles and are easy to clean," she says. 

Sizes: 4 to 11.5 | Colors: 11 options | Material: Acrylic and polyamide felt fibers, Cork

There’s a reason why Birkenstock has been a go-to source for comfortable sandals for several decades. Even Dr. Lockwood gives them the thumbs up for their support. These flip-flops have a molded, rubber-like upper and sole for extra cushioning and support. Besides boasting a cushioned, contoured cork footbed, these flip-flops also, provide ample arch support. The summer-ready shoes come in regular and narrow sizes and feature an adjustable upper strap, so you can easily find a comfortable fit.

Sizes: 5 to 11 | Colors: Three options | Material: Leather

Looking for a pair of flip-flops that have a more refined and polished feel? Consider investing in this elevated pair by Tkees. The minimalist sandals are made from 100% leather and have even been seen on the likes of Jennifer Lopez while she was honeymooning with Ben Affleck. The shoes, made with plush, handcrafted Brazilian cowhide leather, boast a cushioned insole to caress your feet throughout the day. They're sleek and sophisticated — perfect for throwing in your beach bag or tucking into your carry-on for a warm-weather getaway. Our Executive Editor, Nicole Sforza owns the glossy version raving they "add some shimmer and shine to a dress or a pair of shorts while still allowing my toes to breathe. They're fancy flops!" Though she did note she wouldn’t wear them all day long as there is no arch support. If you find the straps are too thin for your liking, our Senior Commerce Editor, Ellie Conley has this version with a thicker strap that she says are "comfortable enough to wear to the beach, to walk my dog, out to dinner — everywhere!"

Sizes: 5 to 11 | Colors: 10 options | Material: Synthetic materials

Thousands of Zappos customers who suffer from foot ailments like plantar fasciitis and neuroma say this supportive pair from Hoka are the only flip-flops they can wear. It may be thanks to the sandals' contoured footbed and thick cushioned sole, which the brand says provides a "unique fulcrum effect that encourages a smoother transition from heel-strike through toe-off," meaning you can walk in them all day without any pain or discomfort. The sandals cradle your foot to keep them in place and have grooves on the outsole to keep you from slipping on wet surfaces. "I don't think I will wear another flip-flop again," writes one reviewer. "I have plantar fasciitis, but my feet don't hurt wearing these sandals!" 

Sizes: 5 to 11 | Colors: 22 options | Material: Rubber, synthetic materials

Available in 22 styles, these sandals have thousands of fans for good reason. For starters, they're made of repurposed yoga mats and are entirely vegan. Plus, they're just as comfortable as that feeling you get when you sink into Savasana at the end of your practice. Not only are they eco-friendly but the flip-flops are incredibly easy to clean too. Seriously, you can just throw them in your washing machine and they come out looking good as new. "If you are on the fence, do not hesitate! It's like walking on a comfy cloud. They will support your feet all day with no fatigue. This is my second pair and I hope they never stop making them," raves one shopper.

Sizes: 5 to 16 | Colors: 14 options | Material: Closed cell foam

For a comfortable and sturdy option that doesn't slip when they get wet, Dr. Daughtry recommends these Archies flip-flops. "They were created in Australia by a physiotherapist who garnered input from leading podiatrists and physiotherapists from Melbourne. They offer a traditional flip-flop and slides. ... I personally have a pair and use them as my 'house slipper', to run errands, and go to the beach or the pool with my daughter," she tells us. The foam material molds to the unique shape of your foot, while the built-in arch support holds your foot in a comfortable position and the elevated heel reduces pressure.

Sizes: 5 to 13 | Colors: Nine options | Material: Microfiber, Rubber

Dr. Brenner’s personal favorites are from the podiatrist-designed brand Vionic because they meet her criteria for a supportive flip-flop. Not only do the flip-flops have an APMA Seal of Acceptance, but they are also the bestselling pair from the brand thanks to the shock-absorbing cushioning, built-in arch support and heel cup that cradles the foot. The front of the sandal is flexible to allow your foot just the right amount of movement and the comfortable straps have a pretty bow right at the toe post to give them a feminine feel. Bonus: they come in medium, wide and narrow sizes, so you can easily find the right fit. "I have seven pairs of these sandals in different colors. It is the only sandal I am comfortable walking in. Great support but super cute too! Get lots of compliments on them," writes one five-star reviewer.

Sizes: 5 to 11 | Colors: Four options | Material: Synthetic yoga foam

Looking to add to your height with a pair of flip-flops? Our Senior Commerce Editor, Rory Halperin, suggests this comfy wedge pair from Skechers. "I love wearing cute flip-flops but, over the years, I've had so many pairs that hurt my feet. I came across this Skechers style and love them — the footbed is made from yoga foam so it's super cushiony and comfortable. (Even the piece that goes in between your toes is comfortable!)," she says. Her favorite part is just how versatile they are. "The sandals are casual enough to wear with shorts or jeans but the rhinestones dress them up if you want to wear them with a summer dress in the evening," she adds.

The sandals are an inch high, giving you a little boost while still being easy to walk in. While Halperin says they are great for everyday walking, she doesn't recommend wearing them for an all-day walk around Disney World or anything more strenuous.

Sizes: 5 to 12 | Colors: 7 options | Material: Rubber

Flip-flop connoisseur McCormick loves Reef flip-flops because they’re "classic flip-flops you can wear and walk in for hours thanks to the arch support and comfortable base that has just enough cushion to be comfortable while still being sturdy and supportive." Besides being lightweight, comfy and supportive, this clever pair has a bottle opener built-in at the bottom which lets you "crack me stubby open at the beach," according to McCormick’s Austrailian husband. While they might not be stylish enough for a night on the town, they are a great option for the beach or errands. "I've owned a lot of flip-flops from many brands and these are by far the most comfortable I've ever owned. I would definitely purchase again when I need new ones," said one happy customer.