I Only Used to Drink Whiskey Neat—Until I Learned the Truth About Ice

I drank whiskey neat when I first got into it—not because I enjoyed it that way, but because I thought that’s how I had to enjoy it. Purists—like those found on online forums, in busy barrooms, and quoted in whiskey books—had all convinced me that real drinkers don't need ice. To put it bluntly, I was trying to fit in with the cool kids.

But as I got deeper into the best whiskey and began exploring its many nuances, I found myself gravitating more and more toward a tumbler filled with a large chunk of ice—or, in bar speak, "on the rocks." And that changed everything.

When it comes down to it, how to drink whiskey the right way is all a matter of personal preference. But, it turns out that ice can enhance your whiskey experience in surprising ways.

How Does Ice Change the Way Whiskey Tastes?

Ice dilutes the whiskey as it melts, but that’s not necessarily a bad thing. For many whiskeys, a bit of dilution can open up the flavors in unexpected and delightful ways.

I experienced this firsthand during a summer trip to Kentucky a few years ago. On a sweltering afternoon, I was visiting a distillery known for its high-proof bourbons. The distiller offered me a sample of their flagship spirit, neat, and it nearly knocked me out with its intensity.

Subscribe to the Men's Journal Whiskey Wednesday Newsletter for more whiskey news and reviews.

He must have noticed my reaction because he quietly suggested adding a single cube of ice to my whiskey glass. What happened next was nothing short of revelatory. The whiskey transformed, becoming smoother and more complex, with layers of flavor I hadn’t detected before. It was a eureka moment. Ice wasn’t the enemy; it was a tool to unlock new flavor profiles.

Related: Put Your Calculator Away. Here's How Many Shots are in a Handle of Liquor

Take, for example, a full-bodied bourbon like Booker’s, which clocks in at a hefty 60 percent ABV. Drinking it neat is an intense experience, one that can overwhelm even the most seasoned palate. But drop a large ice cube into the glass, and as it slowly melts, the whiskey’s fiery edges soften. What emerges is a whole new profile—notes of caramel, vanilla, and dark fruit were previously masked by the heat of the alcohol.

How Does Temperature and Dilution Affect Whiskey?

It’s not just anecdotal; there’s real science behind how ice enhances whiskey. When the temperature of whiskey is lowered, certain volatile compounds (especially higher alcohols) become less perceptible, allowing other flavors to shine through. This is particularly important for whiskeys that are on the higher end of the ABV spectrum, where the alcohol can dominate and mute the subtler notes.

Moreover, the process of dilution releases congeners and oils that can intensify aromas and flavors. This is why many distillers will actually recommend adding a drop or two of water to their cask-strength whiskies. By putting whiskey on the rocks, you simply extend that process, providing a gradual dilution that lets you experience how the whiskey evolves in the glass.

Of course, not all ice is created equal. A giant, slow-melting cube is preferable to a handful of crushed ice, which will quickly over-dilute the whiskey and water it down. The goal is to cool and temper the whiskey, not to drown it.

There’s also a cultural element to consider. Drinking whiskey neat might intimidate newcomers who might not yet appreciate whiskey in its undiluted form. For many people, the intensity of a neat whiskey—especially a peaty Scotch whisky or a high-proof bourbon—can be too much, turning them off the spirit entirely. Whiskey on the rocks is more approachable, and therefore more enjoyable for a wider audience.

Related: How to Make Clear Ice at Home for Cocktails

Is There a Proper Way to Drink Whiskey?

Whiskey, at its core, is meant to be enjoyed. It’s a drink that should be savored, whether that’s neat, on the rocks, or in a whiskey cocktail. Ice allows whiskey drinkers, whether novices or seasoned vets, to experiment and discover new aspects of the spirit that you might not notice otherwise.

The whiskey world doesn’t need snobbery. It needs inclusivity, experimentation, and enjoyment. I’ve had some of my best whiskey moments with a few friends on a hot summer evening, sipping a Scotch whisky or bourbon over ice while watching the sun go down. No pretension, no judgment—just the pure enjoyment of a good drink shared among friends.

So, the next time someone tells you the only way to enjoy whiskey is neat, feel free to nod politely, then drop a big cube into your glass. You’ll be in good company, and you just might enjoy your whiskey a little bit more.

Related: I've Tasted Hundreds of Whiskies. This Classic Luxury Scotch Is the Best You Can Buy